When shopping for a used car, you might encounter vehicles listed as “Cat S” at surprisingly low prices. Before jumping at what seems like a bargain, it’s crucial to understand the insurance implications. The short answer to whether Cat S cars are more expensive to insure is yes—typically 15-20% more than their non-written-off counterparts. However, the full picture is more nuanced, and understanding the details could help you make an informed decision about whether a Cat S vehicle is right for you.
What Exactly Is a Cat S Car?
Cat S refers to a vehicle that’s been written off by an insurance company due to structural damage following an accident or incident. The “S” stands for “structural,” indicating damage to the car’s frame, chassis, or other load-bearing components. Unlike Cat A or Cat B write-offs, which must be scrapped, Cat S vehicles can be repaired and returned to the road.
When an insurer assesses accident damage and determines that repair costs would exceed approximately 50-60% of the vehicle’s market value, they’ll write it off rather than pay for repairs. For structural damage specifically, the vehicle receives a Cat S classification. This damage might include bent chassis rails, damaged A-pillars or B-pillars, or compromised crumple zones—all critical safety features of a car’s structure.
Table: Different Write-off Categories
| Category | Definition | Can It Be Repaired & Returned to Road? | Key Notes |
| Cat A | Vehicle is scrap only. Severe damage beyond repair; even salvageable parts must be destroyed. | ❌ No | Must be crushed; nothing can be reused, not even parts. |
| Cat B | Vehicle has severe structural damage. Body shell must be crushed, but some parts may be salvaged. | ❌ No (body cannot return to road) | Parts (e.g., engine, wheels) may be removed and reused. |
| Cat S (formerly Cat C) | Vehicle has structural damage, but is repairable. Includes chassis or crumple zones. | ✅ Yes | Must be professionally repaired and re-registered with DVLA. |
| Cat N (formerly Cat D) | Vehicle has non-structural damage, such as to the bodywork, electrics, or interior. | ✅ Yes | Less serious than Cat S. No structural repairs required. |
| Unrecorded/None | Vehicle has no official write-off record, or was not reported to insurers. | ✅ Yes | May still have damage; caution needed if no write-off record exists. |
Insurance Costs for Cat S Vehicles: The Numbers
Based on market analysis, Cat S cars typically cost 15-20% more to insure than identical models without write-off history. For a car with an average annual premium of £450, you might expect to pay £520-540 for the Cat S equivalent. Several factors contribute to these higher premiums:
Higher perceived risk: Insurers view previously written-off vehicles as statistically more likely to be involved in future claims. Whether this perception is entirely fair is debatable, but it directly impacts pricing.
Repair quality concerns: Even with professional repairs, insurers worry about the long-term integrity of structural repairs. Improperly repaired structural damage could compromise safety in future accidents.
Limited insurer options: Not all insurance companies will cover Cat S vehicles, reducing competition and potentially increasing prices among those that do.
Additional inspection requirements: Some insurers require independent engineer reports before offering coverage, adding to your initial costs.
The Legal Requirements for Cat S Cars
A Cat S car is not safe to drive until professionally repaired and must meet specific legal requirements before returning to the road. The vehicle must undergo structural repairs by a qualified professional, addressing all damage identified in the insurance assessment. After repairs, the car requires re-registration with the DVLA, which will annotate the V5C logbook to show the vehicle’s write-off history.
Many insurers also require an independent engineer’s report confirming the repairs meet safety standards. This inspection typically costs £150-300 but provides essential documentation for insurance purposes and future resale. The engineer will check that all structural repairs have been completed to professional standards, ensuring the vehicle’s crashworthiness has been restored.
Can Cat S Vehicles be Repaired?
Yes—Cat S vehicles can be safely repaired, provided the structural damage is correctly addressed by qualified professionals. The “S” classification indicates structural damage, but this doesn’t always mean the vehicle is unsafe to fix. If the damage is relatively light—for example, affecting bolt-on components or non-critical areas—repairs can be straightforward and result in a roadworthy, reliable car.
The key to a successful Cat S repair is ensuring all work meets strict safety and structural integrity standards. This means using properly certified repair facilities, following manufacturer guidelines, and completing independent engineering inspections where required. When done correctly, repairs can restore the vehicle’s crashworthiness to its original level.
It’s also essential to choose suitable replacement parts that meet or exceed the vehicle’s original specifications. For any structural repairs, only parts that ensure the integrity of key safety zones—like the chassis, A-pillars, or crumple zones—should be considered.
While full OEM replacements are ideal, parts availability and cost can vary. Autodoc experts say that refurbished or remanufactured parts can be a cost-effective alternative for many repairs, potentially reducing expenses in areas where vehicle structure isn’t a concern, such as replacing a damaged alternator.
Ultimately, if the damage is minor and professionally repaired, there is usually no reason to worry about the safety or reliability of a Cat S vehicle. The most important step is verifying the repair quality through documentation and expert evaluation.
Finding Insurance for Your Cat S Vehicle
Cat S refers to a specific category that requires careful consideration when seeking insurance. Start by being completely transparent with potential insurers about the vehicle’s history. Failing to disclose a Cat S classification could invalidate your policy, leaving you personally liable for any claims.
Compare quotes from multiple providers, including specialist insurers who focus on previously written-off vehicles. These specialists often have more competitive rates than mainstream insurers for Cat S cars. Consider using comparison websites, but also contact insurers directly, as not all companies appear on comparison platforms.
Keep all documentation relating to repairs, including receipts, engineer reports, and before-and-after photographs. Comprehensive documentation can help negotiate better rates and prove the quality of repairs to sceptical insurers. Some insurers may offer reduced premiums if you can demonstrate exceptional repair quality through detailed documentation.
Is Buying a Cat S Car Worth It?
The decision to purchase a Cat S vehicle depends on several factors beyond insurance costs. The initial purchase price of a Cat S car typically sits 20-40% below market value for an equivalent non-written-off vehicle. This discount can offset higher insurance premiums, particularly for drivers planning to keep the car long-term.
Consider your mechanical knowledge and access to affordable repairs. If you have connections in the motor trade or strong DIY skills, maintaining a Cat S vehicle might prove more economical. However, remember that some manufacturers may void remaining warranties on written-off vehicles, potentially increasing future maintenance costs.
Resale value represents another crucial consideration. Cat S vehicles typically depreciate faster than standard cars and have a smaller pool of potential buyers. If you plan to sell within a few years, the combination of higher insurance costs and lower resale value might eliminate any initial savings.
Tips for Reducing Cat S Insurance Costs
While Cat S cars generally cost more to insure, several strategies can help minimise premiums:
Increase your voluntary excess: Accepting a higher excess demonstrates confidence in the vehicle’s condition and your driving, potentially reducing premiums by 10-15%.
Add security features: Installing approved alarms, immobilisers, or tracking devices can reduce premiums, particularly for higher-value Cat S vehicles.
Limit your mileage: If you’re using the Cat S car as a second vehicle, a limited mileage policy could offer significant savings.
Build your no-claims bonus: Maintaining a clean driving record becomes even more important with a Cat S vehicle, as insurers already view it as higher risk.
Consider telematics insurance: Black box policies that monitor your driving could help prove you’re a safe driver, potentially offsetting the Cat S risk factor.
The Bottom Line
Cat S cars are typically more expensive to insure, with premiums running 15-20% higher than equivalent non-written-off vehicles. However, this increase must be weighed against the substantial purchase price savings these vehicles offer. For buyers willing to thoroughly research a vehicle’s repair history, maintain comprehensive documentation, and shop around for insurance, a Cat S car can still represent good value.
The key to success lies in transparency, thorough inspection, and realistic expectations about ongoing costs. While the insurance premium will likely be higher, the right Cat S vehicle—properly repaired and carefully maintained—can provide reliable, safe transportation at an overall lower cost than buying a standard used car. Just ensure you factor in all costs, including insurance, before making your decision.
Comment